Research Portal
Sources highlighted in blue are available for check out in the library
LABOR LAW
Labor law in the U.S. is slightly different depending on whether you work for a public or private employer. If you work for state or local government, you’re covered by your state’s labor law; if you work in the private sector – no matter where in the country you are – you’re covered by the federal National Labor Relations Act. State laws vary widely – including some places where public employees have no right to collective bargaining – as seen in this table. But generally, public sector laws are stronger, public employees have more rights under law (such as a first amendment right to free speech), and public employers are less aggressively anti-union; for all these reasons, the share of workers who have a union is much higher in the public sector as in the private, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
The federal National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) was adopted in the 1930s, and still is still shaped by the politics of that time. For instance, in order to get southern Senators to vote for the bill, its sponsors excluded the occupations with heaviest concentration of Black workers – including agricultural and domestic workers. To this day, farmworkers and domestic workers have no right to unionize under federal law. The one time when federal law was significantly amended since its original adoption was in the late 1940s, at the height of McCarthyism, with the Taft-Hartley Act that made it possible for states to adopt so-called “right to work” laws designed to weaken unions and minimize organizing. For one history of how both the NLRA and the Taft-Hartley amendments helped shape the racialization of the U.S. labor market, see Cedric DeLeon’s The Origins of Right to Work (2015).
If you’re trying to figure out what rights you have under labor law, some of the best and most accessible books are Robert Schwartz’s The Legal Rights of Union Stewards and Staughton Lynd’s Labor Law for the Rank & Filer: Building Solidarity While Staying Clear of the Law.
Most people who hear there are elections in the workplace for people to decide whether they want to have a union then assume these elections must work more or less the same as elections to public office. In fact, the NLRA election process gives tremendously one-sided power to the employer, including making it easy for employers to fire union supporters with little or no repercussions. For an examination of how the NLRA compared with International standards of democracy and human rights, see Lance Compa’s book Unfair Advantage: Workers' Freedom of Association in the United States Under International Human Rights Standards. For an assessment of how NLRB election procedures compare with American norms for what defines “free and fair” elections, see LERC faculty member Gordon Lafer’s testimony to the U.S. Congress or Columbia University Law professor Kate Andrias’ article “A Robust Public Debate: Realizing Free Speech in Union Representation Elections,” Yale Law Review.
While there has not been sufficient political consensus to reform federal labor law in the past 75 years, there are many ideas and proposals for how the law might work better. These include Charlie Morris’ The Blue Eagle At Work – arguing that even minority unions should have the legal right to negotiate contracts; Canadian political scientist Roy Adams’ article “Choice or Voice: Rethinking American Labor Policy in Light of International Human Rights Consensus” arguing that all workers should have either a union or a democratically elected employees’ council empowered to negotiate with management – or Penn State law professor Ellen Dannin’s Taking Back the Workers' Law: How to Fight the Assault on Labor Rights.