Research Portal

Sources highlighted in blue are available for check out in the library

UNION ORGANIZING

To understand the mechanics of how to organize a union in your workplace, the best books are Secrets of a Successful Organizer (co-authored by LERC faculty member Mark Brenner) and Jane McAlevey’s No Shortcuts: Organizing for Power in the New Gilded Age.  For workers trying to get a start organizing against injustices in their workplace, another classic place to start is Jane Slaughter’s A Troublemaker’s Handbook: How to Fight Back and Win.

There are a lot of books that tell the story of particular organizing drives.  A relatively recent account is Steven Ashby’s A Fight for the Soul of Public Education: The Story of the Chicago Teachers Strike (2016).  Jaz Brisack – the person who organized the first Starbucks in Buffalo, NY, and went on to head the national Starbucks campaign – tells about that organizing effort and urges college graduates to organize their own workplaces in Get on the Job and Organize: Standing Up for a Better Workplace and a Better World (2025).

There are only two Hollywood movies ever made about union organizing, and both are old: 1979’s Norma Rae, starring Sally Field as a North Carolina textile worker organizing her workplace, and 2000’s Bread and Roses starring Pilar Padilla and Adrien Brody leading an organizing campaign of custodians in downtown Los Angeles.  Both of them are both dated and romanticized versions of what organizing is like, but they also provide a good window onto the dynamics, tensions and challenges of organizing a union. 

Over the decades, there have been continuing debates about the nature of organizing, the best model of organizing, and about why it remains so hard for workers to get together, stand up to their boss, and win a fair contract.  Almost 100 years ago, A.J. Muste wrote a short, brilliant article titled “Army and Town Meeting” explaining that unions by nature are internally contradictory organizations that have to act, on the one hand, with the discipline and unanimity of an army and, on the other hand, with the openness and public dissent of a town meeting.  Organizing, as Muste describes it, is something like trying to create a militant army in a setting where no one can issue orders, everyone is a volunteer, and everyone is encouraged to think for themselves and advocate for their own opinions.  The tensions, honesty and emotional bravery required to build that kind of organization lie at the heart of organizers’ work.  One of the books that translates Muste’s ideas into the present, and lays out guidelines for building a militant but free and voluntary organization, is Jane McAlevey’s A Collective Bargain: Unions, Organizing and the Fight for Democracy (2020).

Many people have raised concerns that unions are too narrowly focused on the needs of their members, and need to function more as vehicles for advancing working class people generally.  One such critique can be found in Joe Berry’s Class Struggle Unionism (2022). Others argue that, given their limited resources, unions have to focus on organizing at companies that occupy a strategic place in the national economy – like warehouses and transportation networks, strikes would have the greatest economic impact.  John Womack’s Labor Power and Strategy (2023) lays out a compelling argument for this theory and then, in the second half of the book, invites a range of critics to argue with him.  Finally, farmworker-organizer-turned-Havard-professor Marshall Ganz writes about how to bring all the pieces together – to build a union that is not a burnout machine, that allows for openness within the union and constantly cultivates new generations of leaders, but that still amasses enough power to win improvements on the job and for the broader community, in Why David Sometimes Wins: Leadership, Organization, and Strategy in the California Farm Worker Movement (2010). Obviously not everyone agrees with Ganz’ formula, but it’s a good starting place to think about the combination of strategic and organizational-cultural challenges people face in organizing unions.

Trailer for Norma Rae

Trailer for Bread and Roses